gotchanewsdaily.com 
When Jamie Redknapp claimed, “No, it’s been the dream start for them. The fact that Manchester City are struggling, Arsenal are struggling with injuries, it feels it’s perfect for them right now. Who knows, they might get an injury, they might have to suffer for a while,” it sounded like a line plucked from Sky’s standard Liverpool critique script. But let’s unpack this so-called “perfect start” narrative and why it’s both lazy and disconnected from reality.
Injury Crisis or Dream Start?
Redknapp’s comments suggest Liverpool have somehow coasted into contention, untouched by the same injury concerns plaguing their rivals. Yet, the facts tell a different story:
Alisson Becker: Liverpool’s number one, a cornerstone of their defensive structure, has been sidelined twice this season. A hamstring injury has ruled him out since 5th October, meaning Liverpool have been without him in big games, including tough fixtures against Brighton and Arsenal away. Kelleher has been brilliant in his absence, but notice how it’s rarely mentioned that they’re missing the best keeper in the world?
Diogo Jota: The Portuguese forward has endured a lengthy absence, missing eight games since 20th October due to a rib injury sustained against Chelsea. His absence has robbed Liverpool of attacking depth and versatility during a crucial part of the season. He’s still not back, having missed Southampton and set to miss Real Madrid as well.
Trent Alexander-Arnold: The dynamic right-back is now sidelined, forcing Liverpool to rejig their defensive setup. His absence impacts not only defensive solidity but also creativity and ball progression from deep. Bradley struggled vs Southampton, and Liverpool remain without the world’s best right-back.
Harvey Elliott: A young, creative spark for Liverpool, Elliott has yet to feature this season due to injury—another key contributor missing from midfield. This absence has been hardly mentioned at all.
Federico Chiesa: The high-profile summer signing has played only two games so far, far from the impactful start fans might have hoped for. He’s effectively in a mini “pre-season” again, and time will tell how this pans out.
Contrasting Realities
Liverpool’s so-called “perfect start” has been marked by desperate improvisation to cope with their mounting challenges. In today’s match against Southampton, they were forced to name two goalkeepers on the bench—Davies and Jaros—due to the lack of available outfield options. This is a clear indication of the strain on squad depth. While they managed to grind out a result, it’s hardly a scenario any manager would describe as ideal.
Similarly, during the recent clash with Bayer Leverkusen, Liverpool deployed Luis Díaz as a false nine to rotate Darwin Núñez out of the firing line. With injuries piling up and limited attacking options, Liverpool cannot rely on Núñez to lead the line every game. These tactical adjustments and makeshift line-ups are not signs of luxury or “dream-like” conditions but a testament to Liverpool’s ability to adapt under pressure.
Managerial Transition and Limited Summer Activity
Let’s not forget the massive upheaval Liverpool faced this season. The departure of Jurgen Klopp, arguably their greatest-ever manager, left a gaping hole of expectation and pressure for Arne Slot to fill. Slot walked into a dressing room with no new first-team additions over the summer, forcing him to rely on tactical ingenuity rather than a bolstered squad. Furthermore, international tournaments like the Euros and Copa América meant key players had limited pre-season preparation. Hardly the seamless, “dream” start Redknapp alludes to.
Misguided Commentary on Perfection
Sky’s insistence on framing Liverpool’s season as a “dream start” overlooks the tangible hurdles they’ve faced. Redknapp’s remarks reflect a broader trend of downplaying Liverpool’s achievements while magnifying their rivals’ struggles.
What’s truly perfect about this season is Liverpool’s ability to remain competitive despite the injuries, limited summer reinforcements, and managerial transition. If this is Sky’s definition of “perfect,” then perhaps it’s time to redefine the term. Liverpool are not thriving in perfection; they are surviving chaos—and doing so impressively.
